The styles of writing used by lawyers range wide. But they center on spare passages that go from point A to B in a straight line. Point B is usually first in conception. It is where we want to go. As advocates, the required outcome is often a given, or relatively so.
Point A, then, is the variable and the focus of effort; it determines both the first impression and the path traveled to the destination, Point B.
Whole briefs may be well written without deviation from this linear style. This implies nothing rigid or mechanical: there are as many straight paths to even one given point as there are radii to a circle's center. And points lead in chain from one to another, the preceding supporting those that follow, A and B, then B to C, and, finally, Z.
Most briefs must employ a second type of treatment, however: a sweeping look from a point arrived at to survey the surrounding ground. Defensive passages are most often of this kind. We are often saying, first, that from those grounds this follows: Point A to Point B. But then we often must then say, to guard the ground newly won, that nothing prevents what followed from being so, and in particular, none of several prominent apparent troubles are
actual: Point B becomes a perch or vantage point from which we survey the
surrounding ground and discuss the prominent features.
Defense is a special interest of the advocate, but the sweeping survey can support the linear progression in another way, since the surrounding features may be positive as well as negative: describing positive surrounding features show the reader that the outcome urged is desirable. This is, if you like, offense - secondary to the primary offense, which is linear. Commonly this secondary offense is a policy argument, or direct recognition that the outcome urged is not only correct or permitted, but in fact right and just - even, occasionally, beautiful.
These patterns, of course, scale from small to large: the sentences making littler point, the paragraphs their own, and the larger passages carrying the great points. In each, the style yields linear advances followed by panoptic sweeps.
This style is not exclusively legal, though when it is not, it risks being high-brow. It need not be; some uses of the style are delightful.
For a short example of this style that is at once high-brow, popular, workaday and delightful, see an old station identification sign-on from WGBH public television. It is a hybrid of legal notice and mission statement; it hits all the bases required by FCC regulation, media and charity law, but speaks to its public in a popular mode. Being television, the panoptics can occur in the visual, and do, freeing the narrative to be almost entirely linear, though there are a couple of panoptic sentences. There is no need for defense, this being a station identification and not an adversarial argument, so the panoptics are of the second kind and devoted to invoking delight and a feeling of rightness.
A couple of smaller observations on this WGBH ident, which delights me:
First, it begins with a "This is..." sentence: a humble rhetorical workhorse and a favorite of mine for beginnings, here perfectly deployed. Pointing and identifying - either "this is..." or simply the gesture of pointing - is one of the earliest acts of communication by any child, as it probably was for the human race. This is powerful because it is fundamental.
Second, there is the dated but beautiful use of the verb to cope, a good example of the use of certain simple words possessed of uncommon depth. The depth of the to cope is that it bears both the more contemporary connotation of struggling to dealing with, as one copes with an adversity, as well as the deeper, older connotation of ably dealing with, as a mason copes with stone. The WGBH use is a rich balancing of these implication, though unfortunately the worse for wear, since the years of intervening usage have pushed these connotations out of balance and so far towards struggles and sufferings and away from valient effort that we hear "to help to cope" and visualize a good person comforting an aging friend in a hospital rather than a strong person helping another cut stone. When writen, I think to cope would have richly conveyed both struggles and successes: a possibility lost to the shifting sands of usage.
Tuesday, August 27, 2013
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment